Trench collapse

Text messages were used to assert that Jamie Mackay ordered the work that ultimately killed Juan Baez Sanchez, and Victoriano Garcia Perez.

Representatives for two men who suffocated after a trench collapsed on top of them in September say in a suit filed Tuesday that Fireside Resort owner and Wilson developer Jamie Mackay is to blame.

“Their deaths were entirely preventable and caused by dangerous work conditions and a complete and abject failure to provide reasonably safe methods and reasonably safe protection for the kind of work they were hired to perform,” the complaint states.

Juan Baez Sanchez, 42, and Victoriano Garcia Perez, 56, died while working in a 12-foot-deep trench at a construction site at 120 S. Indian Springs Drive, a property owned by Mackay.

“Defendant Mackay’s failures and negligence caused these deaths,” the plaintiffs’ complaint states.

The wrongful death complaint includes a photo of the trench where the men’s bodies were found and text messages reportedly from Mackay to the deceased giving job-related orders and containing information indicating the work site was in violation of local and state regulations.

“There was no trench box and no safe means of egress from the 12-foot-deep and 41-foot-long trench,” it states. “Had any appropriately trained person inspected the job site, the fatal cave-in could have been avoided.”

In March, Wyoming’s Occupational Safety and Health Administration proposed penalizing Mackay up to $10,532 for “serious” violations.

The citations noted several unsafe conditions at the job site, which OSHA inspected Oct. 4.

Mackay was cited for a lack of adequate cave-in protection, something law enforcement noticed in its initial investigation of the site.

“No support systems, shield systems or other protective systems were being used,” the OSHA citation reads.

OSHA also cited Mackay for a lack of oversight.

Text messages in the complaint include work orders from Mackay to the laborers and discussion of payment and overtime.

On Aug. 26, 2018, plaintiffs say, Mackay texted Baez Sanchez, “Keep working regardless of what anyone says.”

On Sept. 28 a delivery driver noticed an unoccupied idling excavator and then saw the partially buried body of Baez Sanchez, the complaint states.

“It took emergency responders approximately eight hours to recover the bodies of Mr. Juan Baez-Sanchez who was partially buried, and Mr. Victoriano Garcia-Perez who was completely buried,” the complaint states.

After the incident Wyoming OSHA, the Department of Workforce Services Employer Services and the Teton County Sheriff’s Office all conducted investigations.

But no criminal charges have been filed.

According to court documents, beneficiaries of Baez Sanchez and Garcia Perez are seeking $1 million each in damages.

The complaint was filed jointly by attorneys Patrick Crank, Mark Lagod Aronowitz and Elisabeth Trefonas on behalf of Isabel Baez and Rick Thomas, wrongful death representatives for the men.

“Defendant Mackay and defendant Fireside Resort Inc. failed to pay workers’ compensation premiums to the Wyoming Workers’ Compensation fund on behalf of their employees Mr. Baez Sanchez and Mr. Garcia Perez,” the complaint reads. “Employers have a legal obligation to provide a workplace free of conditions or activities that the employer or the industry recognizes, or should recognize, as hazardous and that cause, or are likely to cause, death or serious physical harm to employees, when there is a feasible method to abate the hazard.”

As far as potential criminal charges, Teton County Prosecutor Erin Weisman couldn’t say what charges may be on the table. The case is still under review.

“I’m still in the process of reviewing the investigative reports to determine what, if any charges may be filed,” Weisman told the News&Guide on Tuesday.

Contact Emily Mieure at 732-7066 or courts@jhnewsandguide.com.

Emily Mieure covers criminal justice and breaking news. She has reported for WDRB TV in Louisville, Ky., WFIE TV in Evansville, Ind., and WEIU TV in Charleston, Ill.

(4) comments

keith romer

these men may or may not have the training . But by any standard a 12 foot deep trench requires many requirements and as a employer it is thier job to insure that these requirements were followed. not having oversight on projects that you hire people to do exposes you to criminal civil liability. I would think if your halfway smart you realize that

Tyler Rowe

I agree with the former gentleman’s statement in the ease in which we can so swiftly jump to conclusions without knowing all the facts. While maintaining the respect and sensitivity to all the individuals involved in this tragic case, we should be aware and cautious about the tendency to jump to said conclusions and cognizant of articles and news that may not be particularly balanced. Juan and Victor will be missed. Not only by their families but by those who had the opportunity to work with them. I know both to have been kind, hard working and provided much to the progress of the Jackson area. Juan was particularly respected and held in high regard in the world of excavation for the pride he took in his work and his prowess in a machine. I hope that time takes it's natural course and heals all those involved.

Jeremie Moore

As is the case with most events in our country the rush to judgement is quick and usually played out in the media long before any facts are known. Today’s article regarding the trench collapse is certainly a one sided view of the tragic events of September 28, 2018. I do not have all the facts but as someone who has personal knowledge of the events surrounding the accident I can tell you that Juan was an experienced operator and had been plying his trade in The Valley for over a decade. The “tone” of the article and as evidence from the first comment suggests these men were put into harms way and forced to work in unsafe conditions. The stereo type that simply because of their nationality and unknown status in our country automatically suggests they did not know any better is not always accurate. In this case that assumption is wrong. The deaths were a tragic accident, no one disputes this fact but I’m hopeful the rush to judgement can be tempered by facts and not fueled by speculation. Jeremie M

Lanny Lammers

Its awful what this country has become. These men likely should not have been there for lack of skills knowledge and Weisman needs to do his job & hold the Resort & Makay criminally responsible. This is like brobong to get your kids in college but WORSE

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Please turn off your CAPS LOCK.
No personal attacks. Discuss issues & opinions rather than denigrating someone with an opposing view.
No political attacks. Refrain from using negative slang when identifying political parties.
Be truthful. Don’t knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be proactive. Use the “Report” link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with us. We’d love to hear eyewitness accounts or history behind an article.
Use your real name: Anonymous commenting is not allowed.
If you share a web address, please provide context as to why you posted the link.