Masks in Grand Teton National Park

People with and without masks leave the Craig Thomas Discovery and Visitor Center on Tuesday in Grand Teton National Park, where park officials are limiting the amount of people in the building in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Commissioners have sidestepped a request from their county health officer to back a countywide mask order that the doctor said could help slow the spread of COVID-19 as visitors flock to Jackson Hole.

Teton County District Health Officer Dr. Travis Riddell had asked both the town and county to pass resolutions showing support for his order before he sent it to the state for approval.

The town voted 5-0 in favor of a resolution of support.

The county so far has decided not to vote a similar measure up or down.

Natalia D. Macker, chairwoman of the Teton County Board of County Commissioners, said she hasn’t called a vote on the matter because she hasn’t seen support from the board for doing so.

“I asked if the commissioners wanted to put it on the agenda, but there was no desire,” Macker told the News&Guide. “I aim not to put anything on the agenda that’s a surprise for our board.”

The commission has largely avoided weighing in on divisive issues throughout the global pandemic.

It did not, for example, make any public statement on the stay-at-home orders Riddell and the town of Jackson pursued earlier in the cycle of the disease.

That’s in part because the town and county’s statutory authority is different. While the town can pass enforceable municipal code, the county cannot.

“The Town Council has the authority to move forward on a resolution and turn it into an enforceable ordinance,” Macker said. “The county commission does not have that.”

Authority over health matters primarily rests with Riddell. County commissioners appoint the district health officer, a position first vetted by the county board of health. After that the health officer functions as a local arm of the state and has the power to promulgate enforceable health policies, like the county’s version of a stay-at-home order issued in April.

“The Legislature’s goal was to remove the day-to-day passion of politics out of health decisions, and I think that’s prescient in this case,” Commissioner Luther Propst said. “These decisions should be made on health matters, not the outspokenness of members of the public.”

In this case the health officer asked commissioners to support his decision. Since the commission did not vote on that request, the News&Guide called commissioners individually to ask where they would have fallen. Unlike the Town Council, which voted unanimously in favor of both a resolution and, later, a binding mask ordinance, the county is split.

Macker, Propst and Commissioner Mark Newcomb said they would generally support a mask ordinance. Commissioners Greg Epstein and Mark Barron are against the idea.

The mask issue morphs

The mask issue has been escalating for weeks.

Health officials said in May they viewed widespread mask wearing as essential to reopening and as a tool primarily intended to protect those without COVID-19 from those infected with the disease. Wyoming Republican Rep. Liz Cheney even weighed in a few days before the Fourth of July holiday, tweeting a picture of her father, former Vice President Dick Cheney, wearing a mask.

“Dick Cheney says WEAR A MASK,” she tweeted, with the hashtag #realmenwearmasks.

But as the conversation has shifted from encouraging mask wearing though recommendations to compulsory orders, it’s become political. Mirroring national trends, a vocal group of Teton County residents are decrying mask orders as infringements on civil liberties.

Riddell nevertheless forged ahead last week, asking State Health Officer Alexia Harrist to support a rule requiring masks countywide. Her signature is needed to make such an order law.

But before Riddell submitted his order to the state, he asked town and county officials’ to show their support through nonbinding resolutions. He was following guidance from the state.

Kim Deti, the Wyoming Department of Health’s public information officer, said the department is advising health officers to communicate with local elected officials before applying for orders.

“Support there is important,” Deti wrote in an email.

The Jackson Town Council acted quickly on Riddell’s request, passing a resolution June 29. When the state did not approve the countywide order before the Fourth of July the town acted again, passing an enforceable order requiring masks to be worn with some exceptions in limited locations within town limits.

As of Tuesday the county had not weighed in formally.

Riddell’s order is still being reviewed.

Commissioners are split

In interviews, commissioners discussed why they hadn’t voted on the resolution.

“I am generally in support,” Macker told the News&Guide. “We should deploy all the tools we possibly can to keep our community as functioning as possible.”

When commissioners talked about the mask resolution the Monday after Riddell requested it, they deferred to the Teton County Board of Health. A majority of the commission never lined up behind voting on a resolution, so Macker, who sets agendas, didn’t slate it for a later meeting.

She pointed to the politics of the issue.

“It’s making a political statement about something that’s a health issue when … we don’t have the authority to do anything about it,” she said.

Barron is generally against a mask order because of enforcement problems. He said he didn’t see how a blanket mask order would be enforced and would prefer to see mask wearing in businesses enforced similarly to the “no shirt, no shoes, no service” credo.

If a customer doesn’t respect a request to wear a mask, Barron said they can be “invited out.”

“If they don’t leave,” he said, “you have reason to call 911 because it’s a trespass.”

Epstein felt similarly.

“To make a resolution that is symbolic at best with no teeth,” he said, “especially with something that’s starting to infringe on personal rights … I didn’t think it was a good idea.”

Even Propst, who said he would support an order and a resolution in support of seeking one, took some issue with non-binding resolutions as a whole.

“I see it more about expressing my support for the process and my confidence for the process than I see it as a de novo review of [Riddell’s] conclusion,” Propst said. “I talked with Dr. Riddell, I’ve asked him about what type of research he’s done, and I’m confident in his judgment.”

Commissioner Newcomb was firmly in support of the idea.

“I don’t believe it’s an overreach of government so long as the order is limited,” he said. “I think it’s a very reasonable safeguard against a higher level of spread and the potential for having to shut down the economy again.”

Though he recognized that voting on a resolution would have been largely symbolic, Newcomb said voting on the order “would’ve been a show of support for [Riddell] and small business owners who have been frustrated by having to be their own bouncers.”

Contact Billy Arnold at 732-7063 or barnold@jhnewsandguide.com.

Teton County Reporter

Previously the Scene editor, Billy Arnold made the switch to the county beat where he's interested in exploring Teton County as a model for the rest of the West. When he can, he still writes about art, music and whatever else suits his fancy.

(3) comments

Judith Wampler

Since most places were requiring masks when we visited last week, I decided that I was not going to support Jackson although I drove many hours to get there. I would rather support a town that allows basic human rights like the ability to breathe! Jackson used to be one of my favorite places, but I was disgusted!

Judd Grossman

Wearing a mask when you’re indoors, or when you’re outdoors and can’t social distance seems like a good idea. I understand the arguments for making it mandatory, but I prefer we err on the side of freedom. Voluntary is better.

Devra Davis

With so many foreign visitors and those from states lacking in public education about the issue, we place the health of small businesses at risk if wearing of masks is completely voluntary. Testing at the hospital has exceeded capacity now because tourists arrive and immediately seek testing. With false negative rates as high as 30%, they leave with a false sense of security and are ready to party hardy, according to somTee of those staffing the test facilities locally. The lack of federal coordination of the supply chain of testing and other medical supplies and clear policies on masking is wreaking havoc in Texas and Arizona. We should not be diluded by our relatively low numbers at this time. That could all change within days.

Welcome to the discussion.

Please note: Online comments may also run in our print publications.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Please turn off your CAPS LOCK.
No personal attacks. Discuss issues & opinions rather than denigrating someone with an opposing view.
No political attacks. Refrain from using negative slang when identifying political parties.
Be truthful. Don’t knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be proactive. Use the “Report” link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with us. We’d love to hear eyewitness accounts or history behind an article.
Use your real name: Anonymous commenting is not allowed.