Driving down the Snake River canyon it’s an auspicious day when you spot furry white dots along the canyon cliffs.

The regal mountain goats, perched above the highway in their impossibly white coats, inspire a sense of awe and wildness.

Mountain goats are magnificent to watch. And that makes Grand Teton National Park’s decision to kill goats — the ones found farther north in places like Cascade and Snowshoe canyons — feel contradictory for an agency charged with safeguarding the nation’s wild treasures.

But it’s another treasure, often hidden far from view except to some peak-bagging adventurers, that’s pushing the decision to kill the goats.

Biologists believe the Tetons’ fragile and native bighorn sheep herd is directly threatened by the invading goats. The Idaho Department of Fish and Game introduced the mountain goats to the Palisades — to create big game hunting opportunities — in the late 1960s.

In contrast, the bighorn sheep represent a population that has been here since the last Ice Age despite being isolated to a tiny, rugged patch of the Tetons where they’ve somehow hung on despite avalanches, disease and genetic inbreeding. The rare herd’s numbers hover from 100 to 150, enough animals for the herd to persist, though few enough to leave it in constant peril.

Protecting this ancient herd falls within the Park Service’s mission to preserve natural and cultural resources for enjoyment, education and inspiration of future generations.

We’re certain the agency takes no pleasure in killing mountain goats for the sake of the sheep.

But the National Park Service’s controversial plan — temporarily delayed by weather — to close a portion of the high Tetons for a short period to shoot the goats from the air has a carefully considered conservation aim. As cruel as it sounds, the move should be humane in its swiftness.

In the past five years alone, goat numbers have increased nearly tenfold, while the bighorn herd has shrunk by a third. Goats now outnumber native sheep. Staying true to science and the Park Service’s mission, let’s avert a total collapse of this woolly link to our Ice Age past.

This editorial represents the opinion of the News&Guide’s editorial board: Johanna Love, Rebecca Huntington, Kevin Olson and Adam Meyer.

(3) comments

Marion Dickinson

For some reason G&F and those who feel they are the ones to decide on which species are allowed, have decided the the naturally migrating goats are not "native" and must be destroyed. The question is why, it seems the sheep are in pretty much the same situation whether the goats are around or not.

Jim Olson

Yet another example of human caused misery on wildlife.

Dan Grassetti

This plan is just stupid. The idea that humans can step in to play God just ignores the reality that the world changes, that environments change. All that will be accomplished by killing these harmless creatures is to cause needless suffering. In the long run, if the sheep aren't going to survive, killing the goats isn't going to help. This is a case where humans need to stand back and let nature be nature.

Welcome to the discussion.

Please note: Online comments may also run in our print publications.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Please turn off your CAPS LOCK.
No personal attacks. Discuss issues & opinions rather than denigrating someone with an opposing view.
No political attacks. Refrain from using negative slang when identifying political parties.
Be truthful. Don’t knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be proactive. Use the “Report” link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with us. We’d love to hear eyewitness accounts or history behind an article.
Use your real name: Anonymous commenting is not allowed.